Would any 1700s English group of 1000 enjoy Thrash Metal?

Imagine, for a moment, transporting yourself back to the vibrant and culturally rich 1700s in England. Now, picture gathering a group of a thousand Englishmen from this era and exposing them to a genre of music they have never even dreamt of hearing — thrash metal. With bands like Metallica, Slayer, Anthrax, and Megadeth, playing songs such as “Master of Puppets,” “Raining Blood,” “Imitation of Life,” and “Skin O My Teeth.” The question arises, would any of them like it? Or is the disparity between these modern thrash metal masterpieces and their musical sensibilities insurmountable?

Let’s face it, thrash metal is a far cry from the melodic baroque compositions, symphonies, or folk ballads that dominated the musical landscape of the 18th century. The 1700s were an era of classical composers like Bach, Mozart, and Haydn, where carefully constructed harmonies and refined melodies reigned supreme. Thrash metal, on the other hand, is characterized by its aggressive guitar riffs, lightning-fast drumming, and unapologetically raw vocals. It speaks to the raw emotions and rebellious spirit of a later era.

Considering the vast stylistic divide between these two musical epochs, it is highly unlikely that a significant number of people in the 1700s would develop a taste for thrash metal. The unfamiliarity and sheer intensity of the genre would likely be overwhelming for those accustomed to the classical arrangements and intricate compositions of their time. Imagine the bewilderment on the faces of these 18th-century gentlemen and ladies as they try to process the onslaught of shredding guitars and thunderous drumming.

Furthermore, musical preferences are often shaped by cultural and societal norms. In the 1700s, music was widely regarded as a symbol of sophistication, elegance, and order, reflecting the conservative values of the time. Thrash metal, with its aggressive and rebellious nature, does not align with the refined sensibilities of this era. It would be like presenting a masterpiece of Jackson Pollock’s abstract expressionism to admirers of classical portrait paintings. The stark contrast in artistic expression would simply be too great for the average person of that time to grasp, let alone appreciate.

However, it is essential to acknowledge that the human capacity for appreciating and enjoying music is diverse and ever-evolving. Among the 1000 Englishmen of the 1700s, there could have been a few outliers, individuals with a more adventurous and open-minded disposition. These trailblazers might have found themselves captivated by the sheer energy and cathartic release that thrash metal offers. Perhaps they would have recognized the intense musicianship, the technical prowess, or even connected with the underlying emotions conveyed through the music. Nevertheless, it is safe to assume that they would have been a minority within the group.

In this hypothetical scenario, it is crucial to remember that tastes in music are subjective, and opinions can vary drastically from one person to another, regardless of the time period. While the majority of English citizens from the 1700s would likely find thrash metal perplexing, there would undoubtedly be a few individuals who would find themselves drawn to its captivating energy and rebellious spirit. However, the notion that thrash metal could gain significant traction and appreciation among the larger population seems highly unlikely.

So, if you were to play thrash metal to a group of 1000 English people in the 1700s, it would undoubtedly be a perplexing and jarring experience for the vast majority. Thrash metal’s aggressive nature, heavy sound, and departure from the structured and refined music of their time would have made it challenging for them to develop a taste for this futuristic genre. Yet, in the midst of this majority, a few brave souls may have discovered a new form of expression that resonated with their rebellious spirit. Perhaps their enthusiasm would have paved the way for the gradual evolution of musical preferences, laying the foundation for future generations to embrace the genre we now know as thrash metal.

Share this article: